Coho Salvage on Shackleford Creek as a State of Exception

Authors: Jennifer Liou*,
Topics: Coupled Human and Natural Systems, Political Geography, Water Resources and Hydrology
Keywords: fish salvage, salmon, state of exception, Klamath River, Scott River, Shackleford Creek
Session Type: Virtual Paper
Day: 4/7/2021
Start / End Time: 1:30 PM / 2:45 PM
Room: Virtual 21
Presentation File: No File Uploaded


Shackleford Creek is a Scott River tributary containing high quality salmonid habitat that is
underutilized by coho because they become trapped in the lower reaches of the creek which
become disconnected by midsummer. The Quartz Valley Indian Community (QVIC) and
NOAA are interested in relocating coho from disconnected pools into a reach located directly
above high quality habitat, but separated by a waterfall. However, both groups are
concerned that implementation of short-term salvage efforts could reduce the perceived
urgency of maintaining adequate in-stream flow, resulting in the de facto adoption of salvage
as a long-term management strategy as opposed to an emergency action. This leads to my
multidisciplinary question: under what conditions, or at what threshold, does coho salvage on
Shackleford Creek becomes a viable emergency measure, the benefits of which outweigh
potential policy consequences? This question is a precursor to research comparing the
effectiveness of relocating coho into similar conditions in an adjacent reach of their natal
stream, as opposed to relocating salvaged fish elsewhere in the watershed. I am
investigating this question through collaborative discussions with QVIC and NOAA, in
addition to using Foucault and Agamben to theorize fish salvage as a state of exception with
all of its consequent risks. This conversation occurs in the context of QVIC’s legal efforts to
regain historical water rights, and within the context of dam removals on the Klamath, adding
emphasis to the stop-gap role that salvage could play in protecting the creek’s fragile coho
population while longer-term solutions are sought.

Abstract Information

This abstract is already part of a session. View the session here.

To access contact information login